The Old Mill Pizza was a staple in the NWI community for many years.  The tradition continues as three former employees partnered to re-open the legendary establishment – with a modern twist.  The nostalgic recipe, from the dough to the sauce, reminds us of the great times and great pizza.  Our high standards of delivering a quality product with quality ingredients is the foundation of our business. Visit any two of our Original Old Mill locations today for a unique experience of blending the past with the present.